WoT 12 - The Gathering Storm
Първото Non-Dragonmount ревю или по-точно бегли впечатления, защото писалият го (Patrick от http://fantasyhotlist.blogspot.com/) няма разрешение от Тор да пуска повече инфо докато не дойде сакралната дата 27.10:
Link
*edit* Открих още едно кратко ревю без подробности, този път обаче е писано от"Jennifer Liang, Director of Wheel of Time programing for Dragon*Con, Special Projects Manager for Dragonmount.com and the Chair of JordanCon, the only Wheel of Time fan", so major fangirl alert.
http://www.ageoflegends.net/?p=107
Link
И още няколкото коментара от същия човек по темата:Just finished TGS. . .
I'm not supposed to review it till the 27th, so we will have to wait and see if the powers that be at Tor Books permit me to put a review up sooner.
I can tell you that now that I'm done, The Gathering Storm is pretty similar to The Path of Daggers, Winter's Heart, and Crossroads of Twilight. Indeed, there is some damn cool stuff in the book, but the rhythm is bogged down by the focus on extraneous plotlines that don't necessarily have that much impact in the greater scheme of things.
I enjoyed the book, as I've enjoyed every WoT volume to one extent or another, but we are far from the quickened pace of Knife of Dreams, or the the heydays of the early WoT books.
Moreover, reaching the end of the book, you don't get the feeling that we are any closer to Tarmon Gai'don than we were at the end of Knife of Dreams. . .
Wish I could mention the cool stuff, but Tor will send ninjas to get me if I do!;)
Patrick
Никак не звучи обещаващо...It similar to Toll the Hounds in the way few events of importance in the greater scheme of things occur for about 2/3 of the book, and then the shit hits the fan.
Mat is gone, folks. It's like the character is being played by a new actor who tries too hard to be funny. A shame. . .
*edit* Открих още едно кратко ревю без подробности, този път обаче е писано от"Jennifer Liang, Director of Wheel of Time programing for Dragon*Con, Special Projects Manager for Dragonmount.com and the Chair of JordanCon, the only Wheel of Time fan", so major fangirl alert.
http://www.ageoflegends.net/?p=107
Last edited by Demandred on Tue Oct 20, 2009 7:23 pm, edited 1 time in total.
Sure your parents might think you're a failure
But no one's ever said: "First, let's kill all the tailors"
Don't be a lawyer!
But no one's ever said: "First, let's kill all the tailors"
Don't be a lawyer!
И ти си прав, Pat ако не се лъжа и осмия Малазан беше нахвалил...
За мен е по-важно не какво се случва, а как, предпочитам да не стават много неща преd безумно изсмукани от пръстите и ръшнати развръзки като в края на 11-и том. Скоро сами ще преценим anyway.
За мен е по-важно не какво се случва, а как, предпочитам да не стават много неща преd безумно изсмукани от пръстите и ръшнати развръзки като в края на 11-и том. Скоро сами ще преценим anyway.
Sure your parents might think you're a failure
But no one's ever said: "First, let's kill all the tailors"
Don't be a lawyer!
But no one's ever said: "First, let's kill all the tailors"
Don't be a lawyer!
- Interpreter
- Forsaken
- Posts: 3462
- Joined: Sun Aug 07, 2005 5:57 pm
- Location: тук - там
Ревютата за момента, които съм погледнал по диагонал от предпазливост да не попадна на някой сериозен спойлър, са силно положителни като цяло. Дори и писаните от хора, които не са отявлени WoT fanboys.
Sure your parents might think you're a failure
But no one's ever said: "First, let's kill all the tailors"
Don't be a lawyer!
But no one's ever said: "First, let's kill all the tailors"
Don't be a lawyer!
Who is online
Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 26 guests